My background
Being an outdoorsy person I’ve always been attracted
to the idea of kayaks and canoes and have rented a few over
the years. Generally I got on better with canoes as I never
liked the tippy, hemmed-in feeling of proper kayaks and was nervous
of white water. Anyway, the hassle of storing and transporting
any sort of hardshell was never an option where I live – until
I discovered IKs.
Following a brilliant day down the Salmon
River in Idaho in an NRS MaverIK in 2004, I realized they were
not necessarily cheap, one-season beach toys. Later I also discovered
folding kayaks; clever idea but it was too late - I
was addicted to ‘bloats’. I'm 6'1", weigh
94kgs and didn’t have any canoe/kayak
training to speak of.
Stability,
CoG, kph
I've been thinking a lot about this lately. The way I see
it, compared to sit-in hardshells, width
for width IKs are always
less stable because you are sitting higher
on the air floor. The same way 4WDs are less stable in
turns or on slopes than regular cars.
In an IK
your butt is typically
4 inches above the hull; the axis on which you pivot
when wobbling/capsizing. And so your centre of gravity
(CoG) is higher, making you relatively less stable.
On a hardshell or a folder you sit lower, just an inch
or two above the hull: better CoG.
And then self-bailing IKs require a thicker floor
still to keep your butt out of the swill, and so they become
less stable unless they get wider. Which may be why you
get over-wide (39 inch) self-bailing IKs like the K2 or
the Padillac which
of course are aimed at white water not touring
anyway. Although pricey, heavy and similarly basic,
a MaverIK II might be a slightly
better touring bailer in the Sunny mode.
Furthermore, I believe one's physique/size can
also create instability in otherwise well-liked boats that
smaller paddlers find fine. although it's not something
I've ever seen mentioned in the stuff I've read. A smaller
mate recently got on very well in the Capella mentioned
opposite; a kayak-course favourite.
Conclusion.
Broadly speaking and not taking into account hull
profiles, IKs need to be wider
than hardshells but they are anyway because
of the thick air chamber hull. So, although they're
usually lighter size for size they can never be as fast.
But on the water speed is
only relative [grasshopper].
Paddle with other IKs or alone and you're as fast as
you are. Stability though
is important to inspire confidence when conditions
get rough. Even for my size I find my Sunny's 32"/81cm
beam (actually a bit less, see right) to be ideal.
Self-bailers do not lend themselves
well to touring alas as to drain well they must be quite
wide to counteract a thick-high floor or seat base and
still be stable. I imagine the Aire
Super Lynx is
the best compromise, but as I have learned owning an FC Java, will be slow to dry. |
As with my bikes, cars and even my shoes - and to paraphrase Gandalf - I want one
boat to do it all. This obviously involves compromises
but has the advantage of owning less stuff.
The Sunny has been
my main boat since 2005. I initially owned
a pre-2003 Gumotex
Safari which I replaced
with a much more stable Solar for
the g-friend. We still have these two boats. I’ve
also tried a mate’s very old Klepper and Feathercraft folders which
packed the same size and weight but came across as a bit dank, and I briefly owned a Feathercraft Java. I give my impressions of these boats and others right here.
I also tried a Wilderness Systems Tsunami hardshell in Croatia for a day.
The foor-ruddered Tsunami was fun (read: stable); a lot less discouraging
than a P&H Capella I was given on a sea kayaking course
(winds were reaching gale force and I left early to save further
embarrassment).
The Sunny is a double but
converts easily to solo use (unlike the similar Solar 2).
Mostly I paddle it solo on camping trips and for a while paddling became my main recreational
activity.
2005 Sunny 'Mk 1'
In 2004 I nearly bought that NRS MaverIK on
the spot but managed to control myself long enough to
learn it was actually a relatively expensive,
bombproof ‘outfitters’ boat – and
anyway was not sold in the UK. Here the range of IKs is
limited, the best value all round at the time was the Czech Gumotex (aka:
Innova) range.
I bought a used Safari
cheap to get a feel for Gumotex IKs, was impressed by the build
but fell out and went round in circles a lot (until I fitted
a skeg, then I only fell out). Then in early 2005 I bought a new Sunny from the same
Prague shop for around £220. These days they're more
widely available
in the UK for around £400.
The way mine is set up now
it's actually just over 30"/77cm wide (32" claimed
with OE seat). Length is 3.9m (12' 9") as they say. In the
Gumobag, the boat with a clip-in Aire seat, Bravo footpump,
repair kit and sponge weighs
16kg. Add a kilo for
the Otter Box I use as a footrest and for storage. There is more on
my set up here.
Construction and set-up
I’m no expert but the 2005 Sunny is made from tough ‘rafting’ fabric
and is simply built - perhaps even a bit basic. But it works.
There are 3 air chambers: a floor (with a pressure release
valve on my model; keep pumping until it hisses) and one each
side. The footrest/thwart and seat(s) also pump up by mouth
or with an adaptor but I've since replaced both with an Aire
Cheetah seat and a 5010 Otter box
as a footrest, so once rolled out it now takes 5 minutes to
pump up. The big OE skeg takes another couple of minutes to
fit (make sure it’s lined up straight down the hull and
it helps to have the wing nuts ‘balanced’ and horizontal
on each side).
For
what it's worth I've lately discovered
a Sunny's hull profile is more or less classifiable
as an SoT California-Soft Chine. Click the image
left for more. Aire's new for 2009 Sawtooth (and the Triton II which is an XL Sawtooth - more on both here) might also be said to be based on this fast but stable hull profile.
All in all, besides the ease of operation, the
portability, simplicity of assembly and speedy drying are all attractions. My mate’s Klepper and Feathercraft
take at least twice as long to set up and are fiddly with it
(and he’s
been at it for years), but of course both are quicker on the
water and look a whole lot sleeker.
Why
not the old Solar 405 (later 'Solar 2') or a Helios 2?
Despite it's handy length, at the time I recall the old
Solar 405 (see the video) came with space-consuming inflatable thwarts instead of proper seats - like a MaverIK
or Padillac, and so was not so readily convertible
for solo use, the way I planned to paddle most of the time. The later Solar 2 and the double Helios are worse: they have two fixed seats and so are even less 'reversable' to reposition a seat in the middle for solo use. What about the Gumotex K2? Good question;
see Other IKs.
On rivers
(up to WW2.9)
Flat
rivers like the Thames in London (movie), calm seas and lakes are of course
no drama and compared to my hardshell- and Safari experiences,
the Sunny is as stable as a raft – maybe even a barge.
Bare in mind I’ve not learned any of the bracing finesse required
to paddle hardshells properly. In this boat it’s so
nice to be able to lounge about, bounce off rocks, come out
of rapids backwards, slide down for a snooze, dangle legs over
the side, dive out, crawl in, load it easily and best of all,
hop in and out with no more fuss than getting on a pushbike.
The Sunny will start to
swamp from WW2 onwards - long before it capsizes - and baggage
merely makes it even more stable. Should you flip (I’ve done
it a few times when I couldn't get on line in time
through longer, complex rapids or around overhanging trees) flipping it back over and
getting back in is easy, even if you can’t
touch the bottom. Occasionally in the odd hairy but shallow rapid I even instinctively
stick my leg out for stability - a dirt biking
background may be something to do with it.
As
for speed, I manage up to 5kph
average and up to 40km days on
French rivers and have maxed out at 8kph/5mph (I think it
was) at sea with a GPS. As with all boats I believe there is
a maximum human-powered hull speed which cannot be exceeded without twin 350hp outboards.
In the company of the above folders or hardshells the Sunny
can’t
keep up, especially in a stiff headwind; the nose I think is
too wide and you can hear the bow splashing as you try to speed
up. I'm not sure it's a scientific analysis but look at my
wide and relatively turbulent wake in the picture
left compared to the yellow Perception sea kayak in the same
pic. If you want or need to dig, the
skeg enables
you to hack away without thought for correctional strokes -
but you still won’t
catch a hardshell or even a lame cormorant.
If hardshells can generally
manage without skegs then so ought IKs and after a year or so
I
realised I had the knack of paddling skeg-free on rivers in the Sunny (more here).
It’s
very handy for shallow rapid rivers as I find in France, as well as WW manoeuvrability and portaging
around locks and weirs where the skeg's brackets/glued-on mounting
patch could get damaged.
Sure it spins out more coming out of rapids or if you drift
along but it doesn’t
bother me anymore; you get there in the end.
In autumn 2007 I paddled with mates in two folders and a hardshell down the Spey River (below) in Scotland from Aviemore to the North Sea; a great 3-day trip. With snow on the hills around Aviemore for this trip I got a drysuit (see Mods and gear) which meant everytime the Sunny swamped itself through a bit of whitewater I could sit in the water-filled boat in reasonable comfort until I could get ashore to drain it, as below (this swamping caused by the pathetic riffle on the right of the pic1).

At sea
(up to 1-m swell, 30-knot wind)
I
did a 5-day trip around Shark Bay in
Western Australia (see resources for short story links) in 2006
alongside a heavy plastic Perception tandem hardshell that
could carry a ton. The Sunny and gear was easy to
check-in for the flight over and was a pleasure to paddle,
even when nasty conditions set in. Stability was never
an issue. Instead, when it got rough I needed to bail with a pump (see Mods) every
20 minutes or so while being towed by the Perception to stop
me drifting away.
Occasional
waves simply
spilled in over the rounded sides as the boat sagged in the
troughs (left) - or came over the bow as it drove off the
white caps, but it wasn’t
cold and I wasn't alone so it was more inconvenient than a
drama. The quartering wind (is that the right term?) with
a lack of rudder did make it tough on the downwind arm but
I enjoyed the exercise and by using the big OE skeg, maintaining
direction was not a problem. I've just bought myself a ‘high-angle’ paddle with
a bigger surface area which may work better in these conditions. Movie of Jeff towing me under sail.
We’ve also paddled in
the sea among the sheltered Summer Isles and
various sea lochs off northwestern Scotland, very enjoyable
and along with the Spey descent in October
2007 we did a day on Loch Linne (below) and Rannoch Moor.
The idea of anything more exposed in the UK freaks me out.
The way I see it, IKs are comparatively wind-prone compared
to a proper sea kayak which sits just a few inches above the
water. Haven't tried beach surfing yet; it looks like fun but
of course the boat would probably swamp every
time. The nippy little Solar might be better for that.

Transportation, loading and capacity
I can carry the boat on my back for a few kms but it’s
tough on the shoulders as the OE ‘gumbag’ lacks
a hip belt; a regular 70L+ backpack with a hip belt would be
better. Mine is beginning to tear at the shoulder straps although
it still works OK as a dry bag as long as the seal is off the
deck. Recently I bought myself an old pack frame and have attached an old pack harness with a fat hip belt for long hauls on foot. If not on a day trip, I use
folding trolleys and public transport where possible; it’s
part of the environmental ethos of IKs after all!
Lashing points
are limited on the Sunny but with a bit of thought using the rope
hole things ('deck lines'?) at each end you can fix most
things down to stay put (or at least attached) should you tip
over. Lately I've adopted a pair of cargo nets off an FC Java
which will simplify lashing down. See Sunny Mods.
Two-up paddling on easy rivers
In 2005 we did a few days on the easy Vezere river in France
two-up with basic camping gear. G-friend is half my weight but we managed
and it was fun. I’ve never done tandem
paddling before and found it initially irritating to be synchronised
after a great week solo down the Dordogne, but it was nice to share
the paddling, have a chat and goof about. Since then I’ve
also goofed off two-up on a canal in Devon when
setting up matey's folder was too much hassle. Easy or warm
whitewater would be fun two-up and unloaded, but to do that
in the UK you have to leave the country - or dress
up.
Sunny summary 
For what I paid and what I’ve done with it, my 2005 model Sunny has been a great introduction to paddling. My sea- and WW experiences above flag
up the it’s limitations: a lack of self-bailing/easy swampage, but
let’s face it, with a name like 'Sunny' it’s clearly
pitched as a rec boat (motorhomers and barge people often express an
interest).
While this may be the case, I get the impression it’s
one of the best in its class, even with rising prices. It's stability, ease of use and of course portability (pic right: take-out near London Bridge) is all part of this appeal.
Note in 2009: the new 'Mk 3' Sunny available retains all the improvements of the 'Mk 2' 2007 model (many which I applied to my 2005 'Mk1' boat to make it more functional), but significantly, returns to the full Nitrilon coating inside the hull which the Mk 2 model dropped. If you're buying new make sure you know the difference. New Mk 3 weight 1 kilo more than Mk2 (or same as Mk 1), but has full coating making it quicker drying and much more durable.
Sunny
Sunny!
• 2009 on wards Mk 3 model is fully coated again
• Inexpensive for what it can
do
• Tough,
durable fabric, uncomplicated design
• Light(16kg/35lbs)
• Very stable, but fast enough
• Simple set-up and packing (10-15 mins)
• Quick drying (except Mk 2 model)
• Converts to twin use quickly
• Skeg-free straightlining not so hard to learn
• Easy to drain if capsized, and to re-enter from deep water
• Floor pressure release valve (Mk 1 only?)
• There are uglier IKs (mostly other
Gumotexes!)
|
Not so
Sunny
(applies to all models)
• Lack of good lashing points
• Lack of a good OE footrest
• Swamps easily in not-so-rough water
• Needs a skeg until you get the knack
• OE seat lacks support on pre-2007 Mk1s
• Backpack/drybag needs a hip belt
• Could be more rigid (see mods and gear)
• 2007 'Mk 2' models are not coated inside (but now Mk3 2009 onwards are again)
• It's heavy to lug around for day paddles using public transport - a light trolley helps
|
|